QUOTE (Overstreet @ Mar 13 2008, 10:59 AM)

The 45 minutes I sat through before I walked out deserve

.
It's a disaster. Pegg tries hard, but almost nothing works. The slapstick is obvious and poorly executed. Thandie Newton is as radiant as usual, but she's utterly unbelievable as a character. Hank Azaria is spectacularly miscast. And the setup to the marathon training section lasts for almost half of the movie. There's a cute segment or two about Newton's young son who is preoccupied with The Lord of the Rings. The editing is terrible. When Pegg and Newton have conversations, the back-and-forth close-ups make it hard to believe that the two are even standing in the same room.
I agree. Thandie Newton looked stunning, and I enjoy Pegg, but I've seen Saved By the Bell episodes with better direction and plausibility than what was put together. Then, at the end, I saw it - Directed by David Schwimmer. "Oh, now it makes sense."