SDG wrote:
: Which set(s) would you recommend as the most effective way of collecting what there is out there to get?
Hmmm. I haven't done a side-by-side analysis just yet, but with a bit of a memory jog from Amazon.com, I believe it goes something like this:
These are the four editions released on DVD in North America:
- Fox -- 1999 or thereabouts (it was already out of print by the time I got my DVD player on Boxing Day 2000)
- Warner -- 2001
- DreamWorks -- 2005
- Lionsgate -- 2007
And these are the various extras that have appeared, and the discs on which they have appeared:
- Nick Park's early animations [1999, 2001]
- Inside the Wrong Trousers [excerpts 1999, excerpts 2001, full 2007]
- BBC Christmas interstitials [1999, 2001]
- Introduction by Nick Park [2001]
- Audio commentaries [2001, 2007]
- The Amazing World/Adventures of Wallace & Gromit [2001, 2007]
- Biographies (text, not video) [2001]
- History of Aardman (text, not video) [2001]
- Storyboards for The Wrong Trousers and A Close Shave [2001]
- Behind the Scenes: A Close Shave [2001]
- Scrapbook with blueprints and photo gallery [2001, 2007]
- Robbie the Reindeer trailer [2001]
- Cracking Contraptions [2005, 2007]
- Behind the Scenes of Cracking Contraptions [2005]
- Sneak Peek of The Curse of the Were-Rabbit [2005]
- The Digital Special Effects in A Close Shave [2007]
- Shaun the Sheep episodes: Off the Baa! and Bathtime [2007]
So it looks like you'd pretty much have to get All Four versions if you wanted to have all the bonus features, etc. The 1999 version is obviously the most redundant, and could normally be ignored outright -- but it is also the only version that has the original soundtrack for
The Wrong Trousers. (I gather its picture quality is slightly better than that of the 2001 version, as well; I don't know how either of those versions compares to the 2005 or 2007 versions.)
But, those concerns aside, it looks like the best bet for collecting the bonus features (and the extra animated short-shorts, such as Cracking Contraptions, the BBC Christmas interstitials and the bonus Shaun the Sheep cartoon) would be to get the 2001 and 2007 versions. Then you'd only be missing the behind-the-scenes featurette on Cracking Contraptions and the Sneak Peek of Were-Rabbit, both of which are on the 2005 version.
Caveat: It is possible that some of the extras have been modified.
I am hoping, for example, that the selection of "early works" by Nick Park is identical between the 1999 and 2001 editions. Ditto the items collected in the "scrapbooks" on the 2001 and 2007 editions.
And since I own the 2001 and 2007 versions, I briefly checked a few seconds of the audio commentaries to make sure they were identical -- and they were, pretty much. The only difference I noticed is that, whereas the 2001 version (accidentally?) kept the original soundtrack to
The Wrong Trousers playing in the background, the 2007 version has the newer version playing in the background, with 'He's a Jolly Good Fellow' replacing 'Happy Birthday', etc.
I checked a few of the other bonus features as well -- and I noticed that a featurette called "The Amazing World of Wallace & Gromit" on the 2001 edition begins exactly the same way as a featurette called "The Amazing Adventures of Wallace & Gromit" on the 2007 edition ... but the 2001 version is 15 seconds longer than the 2007 version. I haven't a clue why that is.
I also note that the packaging on the 1999 edition clearly states that it contains only EXCERPTS from 'Inside The Wrong Trousers', but the packaging on the 2001 and 2007 versions do not state any such thing. However, the 2001 version of that featurette is less than 8 minutes long, while the 2007 version of that featurette is something like 24 minutes long. I don't know whether the 2001 version has the same set of excerpts as the 1999 version. And I am assuming for now that the 2007 version is the "full" version, though I suppose it is possible that it, too, is cut down from an even longer version, and that the excerpts on the 1999 and/or 2001 versions contained footage that escaped the 2007 version.
What, me, an obsessive collector?