Report from Claremont:This was a great experience! There were about 2 dozen of us in the class, led by Marjorie Suchocki, prof. emerita of Claremont School of Theology, and Jim Wall, Sr. Contributing Editor (former editor) of
The Christian Century. Both of them are veterans (Wall for nearly a quater century) of ecumenical juries at Montreal and Berlin Film Festivals.
Our challenge was to serve as the jury for the festival and decide which of the films best fit the selection criteria:
QUOTE
- The film shall exhibit artistic excellence in screenplay, music and filming technique.
- The film shall promote the common good, which is defined as a society in which persons and communities care for one another's well-being.
- The film shall exhibit sensitivity to the human condition, promoting the dignity of all.
- As appropriate to the film's subject matter, the film shall foster ecological responsibility.
- The film shall cultivate a realistic hope of creative transformation.
Seeing ten features and ten shorts in 3.5 days was pretty hectic when you consider there were discussions of features in the theater after the screenings and then we'd head back to our jury room to further discuss the films. (We're talking 12 hour days, plus commute time for me.) The discussions were marvelous - as good as some of our discussions here, except they had the advantage of immediateness. I'm hoping one or two of them may be joining us here at some point.
The process was not so much which was our favorite, but which best exemplified the criteria. We also took a straw poll for our favorites regardless of the criteria.
The schedule was such that on Saturday afternoon, we had to settle on a tentative winner, and then after the evening screening, we went out to the lobby to see if the final film would displace our choice -- and it did.
The winner of the Whitehead Prize for 2005:
Barbarian Invasions(Runner-up:
In America)
Special mention to
Winged MigrationBest Short:
And the Redman Turned GreenHonerable Mention:
Little Terrorist