Forgive me if I have already made these points in this or other threads, but I just sent this e-mail to a few people, in response to the question of whether Harrison Ford might be too old for the role, and figured it was worth re-posting here:
- - -
It's not just the *age* of Indy that complicates matters; it's also the question of *when* the movie will take place. The first three films, made between 1981 and 1989, all take place between 1935 and 1938 (although, to complicate matters even further, this does not mean that the actor aged 8 years while the character aged 3 years, because Temple of Doom is a prequel! -- so the actor aged only 5 years between the 1935 movie and the 1938 movie; but I digress). So if Indy is roughly 20 years older, then this film must take place in the 1950s. And the world of the 1950s is a very, very different place than the world of the 1930s; the Nazis are gone, the British Empire (seen in Temple of Doom) is gone.
FWIW, I have never seen The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles, but according to the timeline below, one of the episodes there revealed that Indy was born on July 1, 1899. This would make him 13 in 1912, which is when the Last Crusade prologue (in which he is played by the 18-year-old River Phoenix) takes place. (Hey, if 13-year-old Edward Furlong can play 10-year-old John Connor...) It would also mean that Indy was about 36 when Temple of Doom took place (Harrison Ford turned 41 during filming), 37 when Raiders of the Lost Ark took place (Ford turned 38 during filming, which is just about right), and 39 when Last Crusade took place (Ford turned 46 around the time principal photography was completed).
http://www.innermind.com/youngindy/info/indy.htmHarrison Ford has played Indiana Jones on one other occasion, in 1993, for the framing narrative in an episode of The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles. (In all the other episodes, the framing narratives basically take place "today", i.e. 1992-1993, and concern a much older version of Indiana Jones, who was played by George Hall, who was born in 1916.)
The age and timing issues surrounding Ford's appearance in the TV show are a bit tricky. The IMDB says he played Indiana Jones at the age of 50, which was Ford's real-life age at that time; however the timeline I linked to above says the framing narrative for this episode takes place in 1951, which would be the year Indy turned 52, according to that timeline.
At any rate, if this new film is going to take place when Indiana Jones is the same age that Harrison Ford is now -- and if Harrison Ford turns 65 this summer, around the time that shooting begins -- then this film would *actually* seem to take place in the mid-1960s. The mid-1960s!
The original movies were nostalgia trips to the days of Saturday-matinee serials. What could this new film *possibly* have in common with that!?
That, to me, is the crucial issue here, much more than Ford's age.
Oh well, maybe this film will show us how Indy got that eye-patch that he has in The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles. Or how he got that daughter whose family he is apparently living with in the early 1990s.