Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Joel Mayward

La Fille Inconnue / The Unknown Girl (2016)

13 posts in this topic

Adele Haenel is the lead in the Dardennes brothers' next film. The synopsis from the article:

Quote

Production company Les Films Du Fleuve has announced that the sibling directors have tapped Haenel to lead their next film, "La fille Inconnue" ("The Unknown Girl"). She'll take the role of Jenny, a young doctor who feels guilty after a young woman she refused to see winds up dead a few days later. She then decides to find out who the girl was, after the police can't identify the young woman.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A few reviews coming from Cannes. Sounds like this may be a "lesser" Dardennes film, but they're still my favorite European filmmakers working today, so I'll be seeking it out when it arrives in the States:

Variety (Guy Lodge):

Quote

In Jean Pierre and Luc Dardenne’s very best films, you know exactly what you’re getting — until the quiet dramatic pivot that gently ensures you don’t. In “The Unknown Girl,” only the first half of that assessment is true, though what we get is largely exemplary: a simple but urgent objective threaded with needling observations of social imbalance, a camera that gazes with steady intent into story-bearing faces, and an especially riveting example of one in their gifted, toughly tranquil leading lady Adèle Haenel. What’s missing, however, from this stoically humane procedural tale of a guilt-racked GP investigating a nameless passer-by’s passing, is any great sense of narrative or emotional surprise: It’s a film that skilfully makes us feel precisely what we expect to feel from moment to moment, up to and including the long-forestalled waterworks. Though it will receive the broad distribution practically guaranteed the Belgian brothers’ work these days, the film is unlikely to prove one of their sensations — more the healthy arthouse equivalent of a biennial checkup.

Indiewire (Eric Kohn):

Quote

"The Unknown Girl" combines its naturalistic direction with a strong lead performance and topicality, although these ingredients are hobbled by their familiarity. Like 2014's "Two Days, One Night," the new movie focuses on the real-time challenges of a driven young woman venturing from place to place in search of answers from a community divided against itself; as with "The Son," the death of one character animates the guilty conscience of another one; as with "Lorna's Silence," a criminal threat is used to address lower class struggles. The similarities go on and on.

The Guardian (Peter Bradshaw):

Quote

The Unknown Girl, has moments of insight, flashes of perception. But it is not their best work, and very far from the heights achieved in 2014 with their blistering workplace picture Two Days, One Night. The Unknown Woman is an odd, dramatically stilted and passionless quasi-procedural concerning a mysterious death; it depends on a series of unconvincing, and in fact borderline-preposterous, encounters and features a bafflingly inert performance from Adèle Haenel, whose usual spark appears to have been doused by self-consciousness.

Sight & Sound (Jonathan Romney):

Quote

The film thus becomes a detective story of sorts – the Dardennes’ first, although like their last title, 2014’s Two Days, One Night, it’s also a female-led quest narrative with a sense of ticking-time urgency (albeit without that movie’s strict deadline).

There are also echoes of Hitchcock’s I Confess in terms of the question of secrecy and the transference of guilt. Jenny is bound by professional protocol, so anything that a patient might tell her must remain secret; but we also become aware that she’s breaching the codes of professional conduct by pushing her patients for information quite as insistently as she does. The film is very much an inquiry into the conflict between personal responsibility for others (a recurring Dardennes theme) and the matter of social codes and protocol. But, Jenny says at one point, she’s not interested in anyone else’s guilt: the guilt is entirely hers for letting the girl die.

As usual with Dardennes films, what makes the film work so beautifully is what’s taken out rather than kept in: there’s a startling moment when Jenny confronts a person who knows a great deal about the case, but we aren’t told exactly what led her to him in the first place. It’s also a film about restriction: like the filmmakers’ other characters, Jenny inhabits a very small world. She seems to have little social contact, and the detachment that goes toward making her a good doctor leaves her somewhat isolated: the point is never stressed, but viewers might detect a quiet poignancy to the sight of her preparing tomatoes in her flat above the surgery, where she sleeps among filing boxes and other work materials.

 

Edited by Joel Mayward

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Link to our TIFF 2016 thread, where this film has been discussed.

The version currently making the rounds is seven minutes shorter than the version that played at Cannes.

FWIW, I liked the film but found it a bit repetitive -- it kept circling back to certain characters -- and I wasn't entirely prepared to believe that *so many* characters would be ready to end their lives and/or careers over the incident that gets the movie's plot going.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The A&F old-timers will probably appreciate this better than most people in my life. I'm pretty pleased with this photo! The interview will be published to coincide with the US release early next year.

dardennes.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

It's brilliant.

SDG — I have a feeling that you, in particular, are going to love this one. 

Halfway through, it felt like "minor Dardennes," if there is such a thing. By the conclusion, I had changed my mind about that.

Here are some notes I posted on Letterboxd:

Quote

Or, Diary of an Urban Priest.

Doctor Davin becomes one of the most inspiring champions of conscience and hands-on healing in all of cinema. In what may be the Dardennes' most Bressonian film, there is power in this priestess's humble hands, whether she is listening to someone's troubled lungs, holding someone as they bow their heavy head, or receiving their confession.

Embracing a style even more spare than usual, the Dardennes seem to pull back from their tendency toward subtle but poetic composition and symbology. Here, it's all about the gestures.

It's also something of a Dardenne brothers all-star reunion party. While  Adèle Haenel is a commanding presence, speaking volumes with her expressive eyes and her tendency to take strike the pose of a Marian icon, the supporting cast is almost distractingly familiar. Olivier Gourmet is frightening. Jérémie Renier is another walking case of human wreckage. Thomas Doret and Morgan Marinne show up as well (and look, they're all grown up!)

Concluding on one of the most tender and beautiful moments in recent cinema, this is one I look forward to revisiting. It feels a little long; the first half of the movie has a certain meandering quality, taking a long time to set the stage for the intense, suspenseful turns of the second half. It is here that I missed the more complex and poetic compositions of the Dardennes' earlier films (especially The Son). But things slowly come to a boil, one that leaves me in that familiar Dardenne-movie state of emotional exhaustion and exhilaration by the end.

Magnificent.

 

 

Edited by Overstreet

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ah! I'd missed that. Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Still waiting for August 25th.  There is no way the Dardenne brothers should have to wait this long to get a U.S. release.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The US trailer is finally here.

The film *finally* releases on September 8, only a few days after I leave the US to move to St Andrews to study the films of the Dardennes. Initially I found that frustrating, but the film has been available on Blu-ray in Europe for quite a while now, so I'll just have to watch it in that format.

On 10/16/2016 at 7:47 PM, Darren H said:

The interview will be published to coincide with the US release early next year.

Darren, is your interview still going to be published to coincide with the release?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, Joel, you're moving to study the films of the Dardennes? Sounds like a dream opportunity.  How long will you be there?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in the PhD programme at the University of St Andrews in the Institute for Theology, Imagination, and the Arts. It's a three-year programme, so that's my goal--get the PhD in three years, then come back to the US to teach. You can read a longer version of our family's story here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0