Forgot your password?
Guest, 3 Nov 2005
Posted 3 Nov 2005
Nice work Alan
Posted 4 Nov 2005
Here is a link to my thoughts on the new list.
If we are going to have a press thread on the list this year, I can move this post.
Edited 4 Nov 2005 by MLeary
Posted 5 Nov 2005
And good thoughts they are.
Posted 6 Nov 2005
I liked your thoughts on the list. It is a perilous thing to put together a list by popular vote of our group and then all of us put our names on it. I suppose, though, it isn't much different than all of us sharing the name of "Christian" or "American."
Posted 8 Nov 2005
re: MLeary's commentary/introduction to the new list...
I was quite moved by your thoughts - you put fine words to the aesthetic/spiritual experience that I treasure in my favorite films - thank you.
I think I have a fairly unique position within this group because [a] I've studied international art film for years, but mostly only love ones that touch on the very spiritual themes that are emphasized in this list, and last time I checked, I was in no way a Christian. ("jubu" - get it?) Concerning the first matter, here are my stats from the old to new list:
Total Seen: [2004=77] 2005=72
All-time Personal Favorite Top 250: [2004=49] 2005=45
All-time Personal Favorite Top 100: [2004=23] 2005=34
I was surprised that my total films seen went down; and was sorry to see some favorites go (ex. Crimes-n-Misdemeanors, Waking Life), but happy to see some others enter; but what is quite striking (and frankly, expected on my part) is how many of my top-top favorites have made the cut. As a member of DVD Beaver, CriterionForum, IMDB-Classics, etc., and a compulsive movie-list-hound as well, so it really means alot to me that there are 34 overlaps between my top 100 and the new list.
BTW, anyone in the NYC area who want to chat about the second matter over coffee, I look forward to such a potentially meaningful discussion. Truly.
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Already have an account? Sign in here.