Jump to content

Darren H

Member
  • Content Count

    3,109
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Darren H

  1. My first thought when I saw the subject of this thread was body/spirit, which is in the same ballpark as immanence/transcendence.
  2. I forgot about this thread! Since the quarantine began, my kids have gradually shifted to a later bed time, which means I have less than an hour to myself every night before I start falling asleep. I've gotten in the habit of fixing a cocktail and watching something from the Tell Me series on Criterion Channel. I'm a little more than halfway through the collection so far, and it's been a real treat. Few of the films are excellent on their own, but the program has such a clear voice. Most of the films were made in the early-'70s, when I was a child, so it's giving me a new perspective on my mother and other women of her generation. Also, it's just fun to see inside homes, businesses, schools, and grocery stores of the era.
  3. Sorry, you're only allowed to watch Satantango projected in 35mm in a single day with one 30-minute intermission. Like I did.
  4. Joel, I read one of Paul's early drafts of the script and was able to so clearly imagine that scene. It gets me every time I watch it too. Paul guided me through the process of writing a script treatment and first draft of a feature screenplay, and I think about one of his observations all the time now when I'm watching movies. "Beginnings and endings are usually pretty easy. It's figuring out all of the stuff in the middle that takes so much work." They trimmed the heck out of Light from Light in post-production. One big scene was cut completely, another brief scene was added, and I get the sense it was all about finding the pace that would maximize the effect of those final moments. He's really good at it.
  5. I'd love to. Working from home while three kids run around me is starting to take its toll, so I'm struggling to find the energy and concentration I need for writing. But I'll give it my best shot.
  6. Only thing that strikes me as odd is Scorsese is sneaking in above the Dardennes.
  7. Here's the top 25. The number after each title represents the slots it moved because of the final round of voting. The big winner is The Seventh Seal, which jumped eight slots. No other film moved more than four slots. I was happy to see there were no ties. The most interesting facet of this round is that many of us appear to have voted strategically in hopes of causing more significant moves, but for every person giving Three Colors: Blue a 1, there were two people giving it 23, so it ended up in the same slot. 2001 is the most divisive film, with a standard deviation of 8.1 (average is 6.1). Five people gave it 24 or 25 but nine people put it in the top seven, so it ended up climbing four slots. The only other two films that fell out of the standard range of consensus are Of Gods and Men and First Reformed. The four films that we are in most agreement about are Andrei Rublev (deviation of only 3.8), Into Great Silence, The Flowers of St. Francis, and Make Way for Tomorrow. All in all, I'd say this looks like an Arts & Faith Top 25. 1. Ordet (1955) 0 2. Andrei Rublev (1966) 0 3. The Tree of Life (2011) +2 4. Babette's Feast (1987) +2 5. Of Gods and Men (2010) -2 6. Silence (2016) -2 7. The Kid With a Bike (2011) 0 8. Do the Right Thing (1989) 0 9. Ikiru (1952) +1 10. Diary of a Country Priest (1951) +1 11. First Reformed (2017) -2 12. 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) +4 13. The Miracle Maker (2000) +1 14. The Gospel According to St. Matthew (1964) -1 15. Into Great Silence (2005) -3 16. The Flowers of St. Francis (1950) -1 17. The Seventh Seal (1957) +8 18. Three Colors: Blue (1993) 0 19. The Night of the Hunter (1955) -2 20. Night and Fog (1956) -1 21. It's a Wonderful Life (1946) +2 22. Make Way for Tomorrow (1937) 0 23. Sunrise (1927) +1 24. Sophie Scholl: The Final Days (2005) -4 25. Monsieur Vincent (1947) -4
  8. Darren H

    Sophie Scholl

    I mentioned this briefly in another thread, but a great companion with Sophie Scholl is Su Friedrich's The Ties That Bind, which is on Criterion Channel right now. It's an experimental essay film that compares 20-something Friedrich's life in 1980s Chicago to her mother's in 1940s Germany. Her mother was the same age and from the same town as the Scholls.
  9. If they made it today Elisabeth Perceval would probably be credited as co-director of Heartbeat Detector. She and Klotz have been making films together for almost 30 years but it's only been in the last few that she's taken a director credit in addition to screenwriter.
  10. From Philip Roth's The Ghost Writer: "I turn sentences around. That’s my life. I write a sentence and then I turn it around. Then I look at it and I turn it around again. Then I have lunch. Then I come back in and write another sentence. Then I read the two sentences over and turn them both around." I've taught the shitty-first-draft approach to writing because in theory it makes sense, but I also tell my students I've never been able to use that technique myself. I write a sentencen and then read it out loud nand then rewrite itn and then reread it out loud along with the preceding paragraph, and then eventually, when I don't absolutely hate it, I move on to the next sentence.
  11. So jealous of everyone who can write quickly. After doing this for 25 years, I now average about 100 words/hour.
  12. Do we have a target word count for blurbs?
  13. I thought about nominating Su Friedrich's The Ties That Bind (1984) as my +1, but it had been 15 years since I saw it and I couldn't remember it well enough to judge how it fit the tenor of our list. I revisited it this morning as part of the Tell Me series and now think it certainly needs to be on our growing alt-list. I'd encourage whoever writes the blurb on Sophie Scholl to try to see this film, which is a portrait of Friedrich's mother, who was a peer of the Scholls.
  14. Ken, I did this for two seasons of The Public Cinema.
  15. Ken, since 7th Heaven and The Immigrant made the cut, I might be interested in writing something about expressionist American melodrama, also pulling in Sunrise, Frisco Jenny, and possibly other films like The Best Years of Our Lives, The Grapes of Wrath, The Song of Bernadette, and others. I'm seriously considering jumping into a grad program this summer, so I should know soon if I'll have time for serious writing.
  16. Here are the films from my original 25 nominations that made the final cut. Asterisk beside the ones I've advocated for most strongly over the years. Two asterisks beside the ones I'd love to write about. 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) Beau travail (1999) ** Close-Up (1990) Frisco Jenny (1932) ** In a Lonely Place (1950) * In Praise of Love (2001) * My Night at Maud's (1969) Night and Fog (1956) Ordet (1955) Still Life (2006) * The Flowers of St. Francis (1950) The Gleaners & I (2000) The Grapes of Wrath (1940) What Time Is It There? (2001) ** I didn't end up nominating Heartbeat Detector (I chose In Praise of Love for that slot instead), but I'd enjoy writing about it too.
  17. We've trimmed the list to one film per director and broken the ties. Now it's time to settle on the final ordering of the top 25. Here are the rules. Step 1: Assign the original rank to every film you have not seen. For example, if you haven't seen Silence, please rank it 4. Step 2: Reassign the rank of all remaining films however you please. Take care to use each number (1-25) only once. We have 23 active participants in the process. We will grandfather in the original ranking for everyone who doesn't vote. The final top 25 will be based on average score (total divided by 23). Ties will go to whatever film was ranked higher in the original list. Deadline: Tuesday, May 26, at 11:59 PM (Eastern) https://form.jotform.com/201434125370039
  18. Exactly. I don't like the idea of people reranking films they haven't seen, especially if non-voters are being treated as supporters of the original list. I haven't seen three of these films and likely won't have a chance before the deadline.
  19. Happy to do it, Ken. Do these rules make sense? 1. Assign the original rank to every film you have not seen. For example, I haven't seen Silence, so I will rank it #4. 2. Reassign the rank of all remaining films however you please. Take care to use each number (1-25) only once. 3. We have 23 active participants in the process. We will grandfather in the original ranking for everyone who doesn't vote. 4. New ranking will be based on average score (total divided by 23). Ties will go to whatever film was ranked higher in the original list.
  20. My choices went 10-8 and a couple of those losses hurt more than others, but obviously I can't fault any of these inclusions in the list. Great films, all of them. And if nothing else this step in the process pushed me to watch Red Beard, which is also deserving of a spot.
  21. We had 21 voters. And the winners are . . . Bergman: The Seventh Seal (17-4) Bresson: Diary of Country Priest (10-6-5)* Dardennes: The Kid with a Bike (10-7-4)* Denis: Beau travail (10-5-6)* Dreyer: Ordet (11-9-1) Hitchcock: Vertigo (9-7-5)* Kiarostami: Close-up (9-5-7) Kurosawa: Ikiru (12-6-3) Malick: Tree of Life (13-8)* Miyazaki: Spirited Away (11-9-1)* Murnau: Sunrise (9-7-5)* Ozu: Tokyo Story (9-6-6)* Ray: The Music Room (10-2-9)* Rohmer: My Night at Maud's (9-1-11) Rossellini: The Flowers of St. Francis (8-6-7) Tarkovsky: Andrei Rublev (13-7-1) Varda: The Gleaners & I (9-6-6) Wenders: Wings of Desire (10-8-3) * Second place film replaces first-round film. I'm so glad there weren't any ties! In fact, no result was separated by a single vote.
  22. Did you Ronit Elkabetz died of lung cancer in 2016? Such a loss. She was only 51.
  23. Lynch has said often that he likes television because you get to keep telling the story. His creative approach involves latching onto strong ideas/images and then gradually discovering the connections between them. With feature films that all happens before the shooting begins, and I'm pretty sure The Return was fully scripted before they went into production (it was all shot well ahead of the broadcast), but the original Twin Peaks takes some meandering and uninteresting turns , especially in season 2. It's an actual soap opera rather than an homage to a soap opera. BUT the core concept of Laura Palmer, Dale Cooper, the red room, the black lodge, Bob, etc. is solid.
  24. It probably feels so strange because we're all living through a massive shift in consciousness regarding gender fluidity. At least in my corner of the film world, the Wachowskis are only referred to as women named Lana and Lilly, so I assume including them on a list of women filmmakers would only cause controversy among conservative (in all senses of the word) audiences. I don't particulary care. But I know my stance on this question might be more firm than others'. Whether a film should be categorized by the gender of its director is a legitimate question, as is the "auteur" issue, more generally. I believe it's important in 2020 to advocate for women filmmakers/artists/creators of all types because it will require collective action to set right an industry that has been out of balance for its entire existence. Your hypothetical about Dreyer doesn't, to my mind, affect the larger question at all. If such a reel were discovered, it would generate a fascinating discussion among critics, historians, artists, scholars, and activists, and I suspect some consensus would gradually form. Once we reached consensus about how to gender Dreyer, it wouldn't be a sign that the gender question no longer matters. Just the opposite, I think. I know of at least one early-20th century artist who is referred to with non-binary pronouns based on some comments they left in their memoir. I imagine we'll see more of that in the coming years.
  25. Lynch and Frost always knew who the killer was, and once the mystery is revealed it's impossible to imagine the show with any other murderer. The particular crime is the point of the show. When they told the actor, Lynch said, "It was you. It was always you." Ken, the reboot of Battlestar Galactica is my version of how you describe JJ Abrams -- a story with a pretty good beginning and end and several seasons of occasionally enjoyable "let's try out this idea" in between. Twin Peaks ain't that. After spending so much time with Lynch over the past 15 years, I think the main storyline of Twin Peaks and the episodes Lynch himself directs are coherent. There are fascinating fan theories that tie together every loose thread in ways that would make the greatest Joyce scholars proud! If you throw in Fire Walk with Me and The Return, it definitely has a well-designed shape, though one that isn't immediately apparent. Btw, I won't vouch for most of season 2, which Lynch had little involvement with, but if you stick with the show, be sure to watch the episodes he directed, in particular the reveal episode and the finale. I think it's fair to say that Lynch is the true author of the formal style of everything he directs, regardless of the cinematographer and editor, and I think that's more true of Lynch than most auteurs.
×
×
  • Create New...